A Sweetly Vintage Colonial in New Paltz

  |  October 31, 2025

About a block off Main Street sits this sweet, c.1920 Colonial that’s looking for its next owner to fall in love with it.

It needs some updates, but old-home buffs need to see all the beautifully preserved woodwork inside. The exterior is solid, with a dormered second story above a full-width, covered front porch.

A few repairs and scrubbing, and this porch will be perfect for summer lemonades.

The front door is the first peek at the O.G. woodwork details.

The staircase, too, holds a glowing patina while maintaining its original sharp angles.

The wood trim echoes careful preservation throughout the home.

Doesn’t the hardwood flooring just glow, too?

Yes, we agree that the kitchen needs help, if not a full renovation.

But with a price point of $440,000, and the promise of all that beautiful woodwork (and spaces like this that don’t need work), a couple rooms’ worth of renovation isn’t too much to ask.

A screened porch out back is a great respite on buggy evenings.

The bathroom is serviceable, but probably could use an update.

The three bedrooms, too, need a little bit of a refresh.

But each of them is a good size, with great bones and neutral color schemes.

All in all, the house would be a great starter (or forever) home.

There’s an attached garage, too.

On the market for $440,000, the property totals 0.15 acre and, like we said, is just about a block off New Paltz’s Main Street. It’s 0.2 mile, for instance, to Main Course Restaurant + Market.

If this sweet, c.1920 Colonial has your heart, find out more about 13 North Manheim Boulevard, New Paltz, from Jason W. Schobert, licensed real estate salesperson with EXP Realty.

Read On, Reader...