An 1810 Greek Revival Masterpiece in Hillsdale on the Market

  |  August 4, 2025

Tucked into the heart of Hillsdale’s charming hamlet, this stately home is believed to be the third oldest surviving house in town, built circa 1780 and expanded in Greek Revival style around 1810 by Isaac Foster, heir to the original Van Rensselaer‑Schuyler tract.

In its modern incarnation, the house stands as a rare marriage of historic integrity and contemporary comfort. Recently brought back to life through a comprehensive, high-end gut renovation, this turnkey, 2,057-square-foot residence offers three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and multiple versatile living spaces.

Every inch of the residence has been thoughtfully reworked, balancing preservation and innovation. From the street, the home retains its dignified early 19th-century silhouette, with clean lines and classic proportions. Step inside, however, and you’ll find all the ease of modern living.

All major systems have been replaced: central HVAC, updated plumbing and electrical, whole-house water filtration, a new roof, and reinforced structural elements. In essence, the headaches have been handled—allowing you to move in and begin living, not laboring.

The interiors tell a story of craft and care. Original wood floors (pine and oak) have been restored to their warm glow, complemented by plaster walls resurfaced and painted in soft neutrals to enhance the home’s luminosity. Antique glass windows with period‑appropriate casings filter light beautifully, while two fireplaces—accented by miniature carved Greek friezes—add refined charm to both the living and family rooms.

In contrast, the chef’s kitchen is all sleek function: outfitted with Bosch appliances, custom cabinetry, and room to cook, gather, and entertain.

Bathrooms are appointed in Carrara marble, providing a crisp, clean luxury that feels both classic and current.

The flexible floor plan includes four spacious bedrooms, one of which forms a private-entry suite—ideal for visiting guests, a home office, or short-term rental potential. Zoned for both residential and commercial use, the property lends itself to a range of lifestyles.

Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a low-maintenance country getaway, or a stylish live/work setup, the layout adapts to your needs without feeling compromised. And a recent $24K price cut, left the home at $665K, offering something increasingly rare: elegance without effort.

Location only adds to the home’s appeal. Hillsdale is one of Columbia County’s most beloved towns, where the pace is slower, the air is cleaner, and community still matters. Here, you’re steps from cafes, shops, and the town center, with Hudson and Great Barrington both less than 25 minutes away.

In a real estate market where historic homes often come with daunting to-do lists and ballooning budgets, this turnkey home offers everything in one upfront price, with a perfect blend of old and new.

Is this Hillsdale Greek Revival reviving your faith in dreams? Contact Sotheby’s International Realty for more information oon 2657 Route 23, Hillsdale, NY.

Read On, Reader...