Fixer-Upper of the Week: 10 Bedrooms in Pine Island, $425,000
Upstater | June 13, 2012
Looking for a whole lot of space? Or maybe to open a B&B? Here’s a possibility. 16 Feagles Road in Pine Island, NY — a cute hamlet within the town of Warwick, in Orange County — definitely needs some work, but imagine how you could satisfy your desire to experiment with paint colors.

The house is set up as a two-family right now, and has a barn and an old well, 2.3 acres. Taxes are $13,000: nothing to sneeze at, bud not bad for ten whole bedrooms. It needs to be de-wallpapered, de-carpeted, and reinvented in the kitchen and bath department, at the very least.f
16 Feagles Road, Pine Island, NY. $425,000. GMAP.
More photos on the jump.



Read On, Reader...
-
-
Jane Anderson | December 25, 2025 | Comment A Hilltop Retreat in Bloomingburg
-
Jane Anderson | December 24, 2025 | Comment An Octagonal Home Near a Large Garden Gnome in Kerhonkson
-
Jane Anderson | December 24, 2025 | Comment The c.1760 Woolsey-Conklin House in Milton